so, once again, the bbc drama... there's a thread about discipline. and some peeps posted that they hit. as y'all know from previous postings, i tend to disagree with that. so i posted. and i went back to that thread today, and i decided i liked what i wrote enough to blog it. hows that for tootin ones own horn? here it is..
when redirection isn't working (ie, replacing the TV with the 'learning table') try sitting down, and hugging your toddler. say, 'i know you know not to touch the tv. were you trying to get my attention?' hold them, until they squirm to get down. when you set them down, point to the TV and say 'not for X' if they touch the TV again, take them back into your lap and hold them some more. mostly, toddlers are exploring (in which case, redirection should work) but when redirection fails, something else is in play. and usually, (at least at our house) it's because i've not connected with my child enough to keep her feeling balanced. when she feels balanced, she acts right. and i can usually tell when she's about to do something she has no business doing, like touch the TV, b/c first she'll whine for me, and if i'm in the midst of something, she'll walk over to the tv, and stand in front of it. i'll remind her 'not for peanut'. she may walk away and do something else, but usually she ends up back in front of the TV. then, she'll walk closer to it, and say 'no no.' so i know she knows that she's not supposed to be doing it. but she'll put her index finger on the screen, and then look at me. i think this is her way of saying 'stop cleaning/cooking/whatever and come hang out with me!' b/c she knows that when she touches the TV, she gets a reaction. and even at this early age, they understand that 'negative' attention is better than no attention, kwim?
imo, hitting, slapping, popping, tapping, snapping, smacking, spanking, whacking, whooping, whatever, are all just euphamisms for proving to yourself, that you can control a toddler. they don't make the connection. they don't, at this point understand, that, touching the TV makes you mad, so you hit. it inhibits the natural desire to learn, and explore. and as they get older, and more cogniscent, they'll see it for what it is, which is you setting up a powerstruggle that only you can win. ask yourself 'would i hit an adult over this? or would i talk my feelings out?' and then treat your child with the same respect. b/c the older they get, the more they will resent being reminded of your physical dominance. (which is all it is. it's certainly not exacting a logical response to actions at all.)
there are many ways to remind children to act according to your wishes. some of them are 'easy' 'quick' fixes, like hitting and other 'punishments' but these rarely get to the root of the misbehavior. some of them are longer, more drawn out methods, like 'logical consequences and natural rewards'. but even those can get twisted and used in a power struggle. generally, for this age, redirection, and positive interactions are enough to curb the misbehavior.
so many of us think that our job as parent is to control. in reality, our job as parent is to teach. it takes little time and effort to raise a compliant child, but it takes years to form a healthy adult. punishments, rewards, and other methods of control create a system for the child to buck. interaction, redirection, explanation, and logical consequences help the child to learn how to navigate their world in a positive way, rather than in a fearful or openly defiant way.
consider that our toddlers, in 15 months, have gone from squeaky sounds, to words. from being unable to hold their heads up, to toddling around. from a total liquid diet, to cocopuffs and organic fruit. they learn so much, so quickly. and they understand more than we know. so why not set the stage for raising a curious, independent child, who acts right, because he feels right. you'll still have to deal with tantrums, and meltdowns, because that's part and parcel of being a parent, and keeping a child safe. but you can do that, without diminishing them as a person, or treating them disrespectfully. it just takes a little longer.
Labels: rants